Sell Comics Online

Do you have a collection of old comic books that you would like to sell? Maybe you inherited it from a relative who was a collector, or it’s been sitting in your attic since Marty McFly went Back to the Future, or your own collection has just gotten to large. Whatever the case may be, if you need to sell comics, but don’t know where to start to get the best deal for your collection, we’ve got some advice for you.

How to Sell Comics OnlineAssorted Old Comics circa 1960s

The following five tips will help you make the most of your comic book collection when you’ve decided to sell.

#1 – Know What You Have

When you know what you have, you won’t get taken advantage of when you shop your old comics around to buyers. Depending on the size of your collection, this might take some time, but it’s worth it in the end. This step involves some sorting and organizing and then a little bit of online research.

First, you’ll want to sort your comics by title. In other words, you may have Batman, Amazing Spider-Man, Fantastic Four, X-Men, and Star Wars piles. Be sure that you’re sorting by title; Marvel and DC Comics are not titles, they’re publishers. After you have your different piles, you’ll want to organize each pile chronologically by the issue number (this is going to help a lot when you are researching values).

Now, you have to be aware of the condition, or grade, of your books as you do some online research in pricing guides to determine their value. Be aware that finding a comic book in mint condition is a pretty rare find. More common you’ll see comics between Good & Very Fine. As you look at your comic books and those online, you’ll get a good idea of what each condition looks like, and what the approximate value of your book is.

Besides pricing guides, you may want to look at online auctions to get an idea of the value as well. They are often more up-to-date than pricing guides.

#2 – Decide How You Want to Sell

Now you need to decide just how you are going to sell your collection. Are you looking to sell it all together, in smaller groups, or one at a time? You may want to sell some of your more valuable books as one group, while you sell the rest as another group.

#3 – Decide Where to Sell your Comic Books

This step involves finding a reputable buyer. Businesses and individuals who buy comic books in person or online are not always in it for the love of the comics, they are in it to underpay sellers and make more profit for themselves – they especially like those sellers who aren’t aware of the value of their collections.

#4 – Be Realistic about Selling your Collection

The simple fact is, most comic books are not going to sell for enough that you can buy a new car. While there certainly are some that are extremely valuable, most are only going to be worth a few dollars. Usually, the biggest factor in the valuation of comic books is era. So, a comic from the 1940s is usually worth more than one from the 1970s because there are fewer of them around. However, comics from the 1970s & earlier are most often the era that can have some value.

#5 – Sell Comics Online with Dylan Universe Comics

At Dylan Universe Comics, we’re a father and son team that buys old comics by mail from around the country. We have extensive knowledge of all types of comic books from every era, and always offer the best prices we can to sellers. When you work with us, you can be assured that you will be treated with honesty and without pressure.

Here are three easy steps to selling your comic collection with us:

  1. Email us with your name, city and state, a list of your old comic books, and any other information you think we need to know. We might ask you to send us pictures of certain books.
  2. We will make you a competitive offer to buy your old comic book collection. If you like our price – and we think you will – you give us the nod and we’ll send you full payment for the collection via PayPal. (Other payment options are available upon our receiving your collection.)
  3. After you receive payment, you send us your collection via the USPS (we’ll reimburse you for the shipping), or we’ll send you a pre-addresses FedEx label and you can schedule a pick-up from your home or office.

Additionally, for some collections in the NY Metro area or for large collections, we’ll travel to you!

Looking through your comics can be a difficult task; Yet can provide a fun walk down memory lane of when the happy man would sell comic books to kids after school for a dime and make them a root beer float.

Here is a quick guide that will help to identify old comics in a quick and easy guide. We’ll be referring to the term cover prices. A cover price is how much it cost back in the day when it was brand new.

How to Identify your Comic Collection

Through time, prices on many items have gone up, because of inflation. A gallon of milk was 27 cents in 1950. A gallon of gas was 18 cents in 1940. The cover price (how much it cost back then) can help you estimate the year of the comic, & easily identify if they are old. You don’t even have to open them!

Do your comics say 10 cents?

Early 1930s to Early 1960s-10c

Early 1930s to Early 1960s-10c

Do your comics say 12 cents?

Most 1960s-12c

Most 1960s-12c

See many that say 15 cents ?

Late 1960s to Early 1970s-15c

Late 1960s to Early 1970s-15c

Do your comics say 20 cents?

Early 1970s-20c

Early 1970s-20c

Do your Comics say

25, 30,
or 35 cents?

Mid-1970s -25c, 30c, & 35c

Mid-1970s-25c, 30c, & 35c

Here are some newer comic
cover prices:

75 cents, $1.50, $1.95

1980s and Newer, 40c & up

1980s and Newer, 40c & up

Are they Old?

Old Comics typically have a cover price of 35 cents and lower; These were produced in the late 1970s and before.

Issues that were selling for a 40 cents cover price or higher, aren’t actually old. These comics are from the early 1980s and after.

In comparison to the 10 cent cover price pictured; Comics from the 1980s and 1990s are not old. They are old in regular years, yet not in comic book world years. Comic Books first came out in the Early 1930s. Fast forward to the 1980s and 1990s, comic buyers were buying multiple copies of the same issue. This eventually lead to The 1990s Market Crash of Comics Books.

Selling Comic Books

First, we typically buy comic books that say 35 cents and lower. They are from the late 1970s and before.

Second, we mainly do not buy comics made after the 1970s. The vast majority of newer comics are very common.

Furthermore, we sometimes buy newer comics as well. There are certain exceptions in newer issues that have value because they are “better issues.” These are often key(better) ones because they feature fan-favorite classic storylines or contain first appearances of prevalent characters and have value.

In addition, we buy the 1980s and newer comic books mixed together with a collection of older (1970s or earlier) comics. Old and new mixed is fine.

Selling your Old Comics by Mail

Contact Us

Sell Comics Online

Old Comic Books Circa 1960s1960s Marvel Old Comic Book CollectionAssorted Old Comics by DC Circa late 1950sSell 1940s Batman Comic BooksSell 1980s Comic Books for Cash (Ninja Turtles)